We're open for business. We have vehicles in stock that are ready for fast & contactless delivery during lockdown. If you need to talk to us, we've also extended our opening hours to 8pm everyday.

Search for the best van and pickup leasing deals.

Pickup Truck Comparison: Nissan Navara Vs Ford Ranger

Published on Friday 28 August 2020 in Van News

Pickup Truck Comparison: Nissan Navara Vs Ford Ranger

 

Pickup trucks are often driven as a user's personal & commercial vehicle because they blend the practicality of a van with the comfort of a modern SUV. The Nissan Navara & Ford Ranger are perfect examples of this which is why Vanarama has asked resident Van Expert Tom Roberts to put them head-to-head in his latest comparison article.

Let's start with a simple fact: Ford & Nissan understand how to make good personal & commercial vehicles. Ford's van & car ranges are extensive & sell very well, Nissan has a similarly extensive range of vehicles & is a clear market leader at the electric end of the market. The Ford Ranger & Nissan Navara, therefore, are 2 pickup trucks that come from good stock & before I started writing this article I rated them both equally high on my list of favourite pickups trucks.

Today, I think that pickups all look the same - they may have different badges & headlight styling, but there's not a lot to choose from when it comes to looks. The same can be said of their loading bays - they're all 1.5m wide by 1.5m long boxes in double cab pickup trucks & capable of carrying loads just over 1,000kg in weight. Capabilities are so similar across the market that you must be more selective to ensure you get what you need from a pickup.

This is why putting these 2 vehicles head-to-head must be done on harsher terms & why I feel that pickup trucks in general need to be rated more strongly on their cabins & engines above anything else. So, that's what I've done.

 

Under The Bonnet

Things get interesting straight away - engines are the first place these 2 behemoths of the pickup truck world are noticeably different.

Nissan continues to use the excellent 2.3-litre four-cylinder dCi turbodiesel engines in the Navara available in 163hp (despite Nissan often calling the "160hp version") & 190hp power outputs. These are brilliant engines giving customers a simple choice between 'powerful' & 'more powerful'. They offer up excellent real-world running costs & Nissan's incredible five-year (100,000-mile) warranty with long servicing intervals is the icing on the cake.

Meanwhile, Ford has replaced the Ranger's 2.2-litre engines of old with 3 new 2.0-litre EcoBlue four-cylinder turbodiesels available in 130hp single turbo, 170hp single turbo & 213hp bi-turbo power outputs. These are also brilliant engines, but against the Navara I always question the inclusion of the lower-power 130hp engine. Personally, I think that it's an addition that only makes sense from a budget point of view, which is a shame because the 170hp & 213hp engines are so good I hate the idea that people might miss out on them.

Tom's Winner: The Nissan Navara wins for me on the simplicity of the engines available & the no-nonsense confidence boost that the 5-year warranty offers customers. Ford's engines are excellent & reliable, but I admire Nissan's confidence in their offering.

 

On The Outside

The current generation of Ford Rangers & Nissan Navaras are mid-cycle updates or facelifts. Essentially, they're built on the same reliable platforms as before but have been made to look a bit nicer (although that's down to personal taste).

You will find the Navara available in 2 styles: King Cab (featuring short back doors & seats/bench with a longer loading bay) & Double Cab with 4 full doors, proper rear seats & a short loading bay. Double Cabs sell better & you have many more trim options available if you choose one.

Ranger Exterior

As for the Ranger, it's available in Regular Cab, Super Cab & Double Cab styles. The first two are basically single cab versions with shorter back doors, smaller seats & longer loading bays, the latter is the more recognisable 4-door version with shorter loading bays. However, trim levels are more evenly distributed across Ford's range - which might just give Ford the edge in this category.

Overall, the Ford Ranger is big & tough with a new design at the front end which splits the solid cross bar of old into 2. The Nissan Navara meanwhile looks pretty much the same but with nicer wheel arches & great new alloys. There's not a lot else to say here.

Tom's Winner: Joint winners. Like I said at the start of this article - while looks do play a part in which pickup truck you look at first, it's not what you're going to base your choice on. Both the Ranger & Navara look good.

 

In The Cabin

This category is another one where things get interesting - I'm looking for the best SUV-like interior. It's a hotly contested area that manufacturers are competing hard on to get right for every conceivable driver/passenger.

Ford Ranger Cabin

Let's start with the Ford Ranger. It's packed with storage, including a really useful 8.5-litre bin in the centre console. Visibility is excellent thanks to the combination of a sweeping & wide windscreen - the large door mirrors also help a lot in this area. You get tonnes of options too, including parking sensors, reversing cameras, automatic park assist & more. Ford's excellent Sync 3 8.0-inch infotainment display screen comes as standard on Limited & top-spec Wildtrak models, but can be added as an optional extra on lower trim levels.

The Ranger is also very smart with Android Auto & Apple CarPlay connectivity packed in alongside the FordPass Connect system that offers a 4G mobile hotspot for up to 10 devices. That same system even lets you connect to the vehicle remotely on your phone via an app - you can lock the vehicle, check its tyre pressure, mileage & even find out where it is if you lose it in a busy car park. The seats are also incredibly comfortable & spacious - exactly what you'd expect from a manufacturer with so much driver/passenger comfort experience.

 

Ford Ranger Cabin<

Now, onto the Nissan Navara which definitely features a car-like cabin taking all sorts of cues from Nissan's range of SUVs. But, the Navara's interior is not quite as exciting as the Ford Ranger's - everything is where it should be, it works, it's ergonomic, it's just not at the same level of driver/passenger experience. Storage is fine & functional, there's plenty of space (pun intended, because apparently NASA helped design the seats), but there's little wow factor - but then not every user is looking for that.

The driving position seems a little low in the Navara - even more so because of its high bonnet - but the 360-degree camera set up available as an option is excellent & reduces this issue to a minor consideration. Infotainment is provided by Nissan's system which, apart from a clunky interface, packs all the same features you'd expect in a modern system. Seat comfort is good, but feels slightly more spongy than the Ranger.

Tom's Winner: It's got to be the Ford Ranger - across the models it feels like Ford has thought of everything & everyone. The Nissan Navara is not bad, however, just less refined overall. Which one you choose will depend on what you want from your pickup truck - if it's all-round commercial & personal comfort either one will work.

 

In The Loading Bay

Here we are, the final category & the one where both the Nissan Navara & Ford Ranger are more similar than ever. Both can carry payloads of over 1,000kg (they have to be able to do this so they can be classed as commercial vehicles) & in the Double Cab body types their loading bays are simple 1.56m wide by 1.56m long boxes & they can both be fitted with a variety of canopies, roller shutters & pop-top covers.

Towing is also an area they match up on. Ford Rangers are capable of towing between 2,500kg to 3,500kg in weight using braked trailers & 750kg unbraked across the range. The Nissan Navaras, meanwhile, achieve exactly the same maximum braked towage of 3,500kg too. There's really not a whole lot to choose between them.

Tom's Winner: Joint winners. They do exactly what modern pickup trucks are expected to do. They're equally capable of carrying & towing heavy weights. Simple as.

 

Nissan Navara Vs Ford Ranger: Tom's Takeaways

Comparing these 2 pickup trucks has actually been quite fun. I've been forced to properly look at them & weigh up their attributes - they no longer occupy the same spot in my head as "favourite pickup trucks". But don't let that sway you either way.

I rate the Ford Ranger highly on cabin quality & overall experience, which is more down to personal taste than anything else. Equally, I rate the Nissan Navara's looks & engines highly. But in my opinion, a pickup truck has to be more than just good-looking & efficient - the vast majority of pickup drivers use them as work & family vehicles. They have to be just as comfortable as they are practical. Now, they're my favourite pickup trucks for different reasons & I'd never recommend one over the other until I understood what a user actually wanted to do with it.

My advice? Do your research & work out which pickup truck gives you the best blend of efficient engines, passenger practicality & driver comfort for how you intend to use it. External looks are nice, but most pickups look the same, it's the engines & cabins that really make the difference. Happy hunting.

If you want to know more about these leading pickup trucks check out ourĀ latest pickup truck offers.

 

Comments